44.9%The combined marginal tax rate on a cash severance payment for a VP or Director in a 37% federal bracket plus the 2.9% Medicare surtax (no FICA ceiling once wages exceed $176,100 in 2026) plus a representative 5% state income tax rate. A $24,000 cash health coverage payment included in a severance package costs the executive $10,776 in combined federal, Medicare, and state taxes — leaving $13,224 in after-tax cash against $24,000 of COBRA premiums owed. The executive is instantly $10,776 short on health coverage before receiving a single Explanation of Benefits.
$43,557The gross-up amount required to deliver $24,000 in after-tax cash for COBRA premiums to an executive at a combined 44.9% marginal tax rate. To make the executive whole on a $24,000 COBRA cost through a taxable cash severance payment, the employer must pay $43,557 in gross severance — of which $19,557 goes directly to federal, state, and Medicare taxes and $24,000 reaches the executive. Employer-paid COBRA direct premium payment costs the employer exactly $24,000 for the same outcome — a $19,557 cost differential that makes direct payment objectively superior for both parties.
$0The federal income tax owed by an executive on employer-paid COBRA premium payments made directly by the former employer to the insurance carrier or COBRA administrator under IRC Section 106. When the employer pays COBRA premiums on behalf of the terminated executive as a continuation of the group health plan, the payment is treated as an employer contribution to an accident and health plan and excluded from the executive’s gross income — the same tax treatment that applied to health premiums during active employment. No W-2 income. No federal income tax. No state income tax in most states. No Medicare tax.
18The maximum number of months of COBRA continuation coverage available to a terminated employee and covered family members following a qualifying event such as involuntary termination or reduction in hours. At 2026 family plan COBRA rates of $1,800 to $2,400 per month for a comprehensive employer-sponsored PPO or HMO plan, 18 months of full premium coverage represents $32,400 to $43,200 in employer-paid health benefits — the single largest non-cash benefit available for negotiation in an executive severance package and the benefit with the greatest tax efficiency differential between direct payment and cash equivalent.
1. The Core Tax Asymmetry: Why $1 of COBRA Subsidy Is Worth $1.82 in Cash Severance
Every executive severance negotiation involves the same fundamental equation: what is the employer willing to pay, and how much of that payment actually reaches the executive after taxes? For most severance components — base salary continuation, bonus payments, equity acceleration — the answer is straightforward. The executive receives the gross amount, pays federal income tax at their marginal rate plus applicable payroll taxes, and keeps the net. For employer-paid COBRA premiums, the equation is fundamentally different. The tax exclusion under IRC Section 106 means that the employer’s payment reaches the executive at full value without tax reduction. A $24,000 employer-paid COBRA subsidy delivers $24,000 of healthcare purchasing power. A $24,000 cash health coverage payment delivers $13,224 after taxes for a 44.9% combined marginal rate executive — a $10,776 gap that represents pure tax inefficiency that benefits neither the executive nor the employer.
After-Tax Value of Cash Health Coverage Payment:
Cash Amount × (1 − Combined Marginal Tax Rate) = After-Tax Value
$24,000 × (1 − 0.449) = $24,000 × 0.551 = $13,224 after-tax
After-Tax Value of Employer-Paid COBRA Premium:
COBRA Premium Amount × 1.00 = After-Tax Value (IRC §106 exclusion applies)
$24,000 × 1.00 = $24,000 after-tax
Tax Efficiency Ratio:
Employer-Paid COBRA Value ÷ Cash Equivalent Value = $24,000 ÷ $13,224 = 1.815
Every $1 of employer-paid COBRA delivers the same economic value as $1.815 of cash severance after taxes.
The employer’s perspective — why direct COBRA payment is often preferable to cash for the company as well: An employer who pays $43,557 in gross severance to deliver $24,000 in after-tax cash to a departing executive incurs both the $43,557 payroll cost and the employer’s share of Medicare tax on the gross amount ($43,557 × 1.45% = $631). Paying COBRA premiums directly costs the employer exactly $24,000 — the actual premium charged by the insurance carrier — with no additional payroll tax obligation, since employer COBRA premium payments are not wages and are not subject to employer-side FICA or Medicare tax. The total cost comparison: $44,188 to deliver $24,000 in after-tax cash vs. $24,000 to deliver $24,000 in tax-free health coverage. Direct COBRA payment saves the employer $20,188 while simultaneously delivering the executive a larger economic benefit. This mutual benefit is the most powerful framing available in the negotiation.
Calculate Your Coverage
Use our interactive tool to model your specific insurance scenario and identify coverage gaps.
2. The IRS Tax Framework for COBRA Premiums in Severance: What the Code Actually Says
The tax exclusion for employer-paid COBRA premiums is grounded in two connected provisions of the Internal Revenue Code. IRC Section 106 excludes from an employee’s gross income the employer’s contributions to an accident or health plan. IRC Section 105 excludes from gross income amounts received by an employee under an accident or health plan for personal injuries or sickness. The combination of these two provisions creates the tax-exempt treatment of employer-sponsored health coverage — and COBRA continuation coverage is explicitly a continuation of the employer’s group health plan under the Public Health Service Act, meaning the Section 106 exclusion extends to COBRA premium payments made by the former employer during the continuation coverage period.
The critical IRS distinction that determines whether the tax exclusion applies — direct payment vs. reimbursement: The Section 106 exclusion applies when the employer pays COBRA premiums directly to the insurance carrier, the COBRA administrator, or the plan on behalf of the former employee. It does not apply — or applies with more complexity and potential scrutiny — when the employer pays additional cash severance to the executive who then uses that cash to pay COBRA premiums independently. The structural difference is between an employer contribution to a health plan (excluded) and taxable compensation that the executive happens to spend on health insurance (fully taxable). Separation agreements should specify that health coverage continuation is provided as an employer-paid benefit rather than as a cash allowance or health reimbursement arrangement, and the payment mechanics should require the employer to remit premiums directly to the COBRA administrator or carrier rather than to the executive. An employment attorney should review the specific language to ensure the payment structure qualifies for the exclusion under the applicable IRS guidance and any state-specific tax rules.
IRS Tax Treatment of Health Coverage in Executive Severance — Payment Structure Comparison
| Payment Structure | IRS Classification | Federal Income Tax | Medicare Tax | State Income Tax | Net Value to Executive (on $24K benefit) |
|---|
| Employer pays COBRA premium directly to carrier or COBRA administrator on behalf of executive |
Employer contribution to accident or health plan — IRC §106 exclusion |
Excluded from gross income — $0 federal income tax |
Not wages — $0 Medicare tax |
Excluded in most states — $0 state tax (verify for CA, NJ, PA) |
$24,000 full value retained |
| Cash severance designated as “health coverage allowance” paid to executive |
Wages / compensation — fully taxable regardless of stated purpose |
37% federal marginal rate on full amount |
2.9% Medicare tax (no wage base ceiling at executive income levels) |
Taxable in all states — 4% to 13.3% depending on state |
$13,224 after 44.9% combined rate — $10,776 lost to taxes |
| Health Reimbursement Arrangement (HRA) funded by former employer for COBRA premiums |
Potentially excluded under IRC §106 if properly structured as an employer-funded HRA — IRS Notice 2015-87 and ACA compliance required |
Excluded if HRA qualifies — but post-employment HRA structures require careful compliance with ACA market reforms |
Excluded if properly structured |
Generally excluded if federal exclusion applies |
Full value if structured correctly — but requires legal review and carries more implementation risk than direct premium payment |
| Executive Self-Pays COBRA and Claims Self-Employed Health Insurance Deduction |
No self-employed health insurance deduction available — executive was an employee, not self-employed, during coverage period. Standard itemized deduction rules apply. |
No deduction available for most executives — medical expense deduction requires exceeding 7.5% of AGI threshold and itemizing, which few executives achieve on health premiums alone |
N/A — executive funds premiums from after-tax dollars with no offsetting deduction |
After-tax dollars — no deduction in most states |
Executive bears full COBRA cost from after-tax income — worst-case outcome |
The three-state exception — California, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania: California, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania do not conform to the federal IRC Section 106 exclusion for employer-paid health coverage in all circumstances. New Jersey imposes state income tax on employer-paid health premiums above certain thresholds. Pennsylvania has specific rules regarding the state tax treatment of fringe benefits. California generally conforms to the federal exclusion but has occasional divergences for certain employer-funded arrangements. Executives in these three states should confirm the state tax treatment of employer-paid COBRA premiums with a state-licensed tax attorney or CPA before finalizing the severance agreement structure. In most cases, even with partial state taxation, the direct payment structure produces a significantly better outcome than cash severance — but the net calculation changes enough to require verification.
3. What COBRA Actually Costs in 2026: The Numbers You Need Before Negotiating
Effective negotiation requires precise numbers. An executive who requests “COBRA subsidy” without specifying the exact monthly premium amount and duration is negotiating blind — and giving the employer the opportunity to agree in principle while minimizing the actual benefit in the written agreement. COBRA premiums are calculated as 102% of the employer’s full group health plan premium (100% premium plus a 2% administrative fee), meaning the executive must first establish the employer’s actual group plan cost before calculating the COBRA subsidy request. This information is available on request under COBRA disclosure rules and can also be obtained from the benefits department or the COBRA administrator before signing the separation agreement.
Plan Type
Coverage Tier and Monthly COBRA Premium
18-Month Full Subsidy Value (Direct Employer Payment)
PPO — Premium Tier (large tech / financial services employers)
Employee only: $780 to $920/month
Employee + spouse: $1,550 to $1,840/month
Family (employee + spouse + children): $2,100 to $2,600/month
Employee only: $14,040 to $16,560
Employee + spouse: $27,900 to $33,120
Family: $37,800 to $46,800
PPO — Standard Tier (mid-market corporate employers)
Employee only: $580 to $720/month
Employee + spouse: $1,160 to $1,440/month
Family: $1,680 to $2,040/month
Employee only: $10,440 to $12,960
Employee + spouse: $20,880 to $25,920
Family: $30,240 to $36,720
HMO / EPO (tech companies — California, New York, Pacific Northwest markets)
Employee only: $520 to $680/month
Employee + spouse: $1,040 to $1,360/month
Family: $1,560 to $2,080/month
Employee only: $9,360 to $12,240
Employee + spouse: $18,720 to $24,480
Family: $28,080 to $37,440
HDHP with HSA (increasingly common in tech — lower COBRA premium, higher deductible)
Employee only: $380 to $520/month
Employee + spouse: $760 to $1,040/month
Family: $1,140 to $1,560/month
Employee only: $6,840 to $9,360
Employee + spouse: $13,680 to $18,720
Family: $20,520 to $28,080
How to get the exact COBRA premium number before your negotiation: Under COBRA regulations, the employer must provide a COBRA election notice within 14 days of the plan administrator receiving notice of the qualifying event. This notice must specify the premium amount. However, you need this number before you sign the separation agreement — not 14 days after. Request the exact group health plan premium from your HR benefits contact or the benefits summary plan description (SPD) before entering negotiation. The COBRA premium is 102% of this amount. Alternatively, ask your employment attorney to request the plan’s actuarial cost certificate as part of the pre-signing discovery process. Knowing the exact number — not a range — allows you to specify the subsidy amount precisely in the separation agreement language, preventing the employer from later arguing that the agreed “COBRA subsidy” refers to a partial contribution rather than the full premium.
Calculate Your Exact COBRA Premium and 18-Month Subsidy Value
Enter your plan type, coverage tier, and employer group plan cost. The COBRA Health Insurance Cost Calculator shows your exact monthly premium, 18-month total cost, and the gross-up cash equivalent your employer would need to pay to match direct COBRA payment value.
Calculate My COBRA Subsidy Value →
4. The Gross-Up Math: Calculating the Pre-Tax Cash Equivalent of Your COBRA Benefit
The gross-up calculation is the mathematical centerpiece of the COBRA subsidy negotiation. It answers the question every executive should ask before accepting a cash health coverage payment: how much would the employer need to pay me in gross taxable severance to leave me with the same after-tax amount as a direct COBRA premium payment? The answer is always substantially more than the COBRA premium itself — and presenting this calculation to the employer demonstrates that direct payment is more cost-efficient for both parties, removing the employer’s financial objection to the benefit structure.
Gross-Up Formula:
Required Gross Cash = COBRA Premium Cost ÷ (1 − Combined Marginal Tax Rate)
Executive Profile: Family plan COBRA at $2,200/month × 18 months = $39,600 total COBRA cost
Combined marginal tax rate: 37% federal + 2.9% Medicare + 5% state = 44.9%
Required Gross Cash = $39,600 ÷ (1 − 0.449) = $39,600 ÷ 0.551 = $71,870 gross taxable severance
Federal + state + Medicare taxes on gross: $71,870 × 0.449 = $32,270 paid in taxes
Executive after-tax cash: $71,870 − $32,270 = $39,600 — equal to COBRA cost
Direct COBRA Payment Cost to Employer: $39,600
Cash Gross-Up Cost to Employer: $71,870 + employer Medicare ($71,870 × 1.45%) = $72,912
Employer savings from direct payment: $33,312 over 18 months
💼 Side-by-Side Executive Severance Health Coverage Comparison — VP, Family Plan, 18 Months, $2,200/Month COBRA
Option A — Cash Health Coverage Allowance (Taxable)
Gross cash payment in severance$39,600
Federal income tax at 37%−$14,652
Medicare tax at 2.9%−$1,148
State income tax at 5%−$1,980
Total taxes paid by executive−$17,780
After-tax cash to executive$21,820
COBRA family plan cost (18 months)−$39,600
Shortfall executive must fund from other assets−$17,780
Months of coverage fully funded9.9 months — not the full 18
Employer’s total cost (gross + employer Medicare)$40,175
Option B — Employer-Paid COBRA Direct Premium (Tax-Free IRC §106)
Employer direct premium payment to COBRA administrator$39,600
Federal income tax to executive$0 — IRC §106 exclusion
Medicare tax to executive$0 — not wages
State income tax to executive$0 — most states conform
Total taxes paid by executive$0
After-tax value to executive$39,600 — full amount
COBRA family plan cost (18 months)$39,600 — fully covered
Shortfall executive must fund$0 — 18 months fully covered
Months of coverage fully funded18.0 months — full maximum period
Employer’s total cost (direct premium only — no payroll tax)$39,600
The employer pays $575 more under Option A ($40,175 vs. $39,600) while delivering 45% less healthcare coverage value to the executive ($21,820 after-tax vs. $39,600 full value). Option B costs the employer $575 less and delivers the executive $17,780 more in economic benefit. There is no scenario in which the cash allowance is superior to direct payment for either party at this income level — the only reason executives accept the cash structure is because they do not run this calculation before signing.
5. The Negotiation Strategy: How to Request COBRA Subsidy Before You Sign
The window for negotiating COBRA subsidy into a severance package closes the moment the separation agreement is signed. Most executives receive a draft separation agreement and are given 21 days (or 45 days for group reductions in force) to consider it under the Older Workers Benefit Protection Act — a period that also represents the entire negotiation window. The strategy below is designed to be deployed within this window, framing the COBRA subsidy request in the language that HR departments and corporate legal teams are most likely to approve without escalating to executive compensation committee level.
1
Day 1 to 3: Do Not Sign. Engage an Employment Attorney.
The single most important action in the first 72 hours after receiving a separation agreement is to retain an employment attorney before responding to the employer. Employment attorneys who specialize in executive severance negotiations are familiar with benefit subsidy structures and can review the agreement for COBRA-related provisions, identify missing benefit continuation language, and draft counter-proposal language that is legally precise and likely to receive HR approval. Most executives who attempt to negotiate COBRA subsidy without attorney representation either fail to secure the benefit or accept imprecise agreement language that later produces tax ambiguity. Attorney fees for executive severance review typically range from $1,500 to $5,000 — a fraction of the $17,780 to $33,000 in tax savings at stake for a family-plan executive.
Action: Retain employment attorney. Do not respond to HR before attorney review is complete.
2
Day 3 to 7: Run the Numbers and Build the Business Case
Before the counter-proposal meeting, calculate the exact figures using the gross-up formula: your exact COBRA premium (102% of the group plan cost for your coverage tier), the gross-up cash equivalent at your combined marginal tax rate, the employer’s total cost comparison between direct payment and gross-up cash, and the dollar amount of IRMAA subsidy you are requesting across the 18-month maximum period. Presenting these numbers to HR in writing — as part of the counter-proposal — demonstrates that the request is financially grounded and removes the employer’s ability to claim the benefit is unusual or cost-prohibitive. The mutual cost efficiency of direct payment is the argument that moves this from the compensation track to the benefits administration track.
Action: Calculate exact COBRA premium. Build gross-up comparison showing employer saves money with direct payment.
3
Day 7 to 14: Submit the Counter-Proposal with COBRA Language
The counter-proposal should include specific separation agreement language for the COBRA benefit — not a general request for “health coverage assistance.” The language should specify: the duration of subsidy (12 to 18 months or until new employer coverage begins, whichever is earlier); the payment mechanics (direct payment to the COBRA administrator or carrier, not reimbursement to the executive); the coverage tier (matching current enrolled coverage level); and the tax treatment acknowledgment (the parties intend the payment to qualify for exclusion from gross income under IRC Section 106). Including this level of specificity signals to the employer’s legal team that the request has been professionally prepared and that the structure is legally sound — reducing the likelihood of a blanket refusal based on novelty concerns.
Action: Submit written counter-proposal with precise COBRA language drafted by employment attorney.
4
Day 14 to 21: Navigate the HR and Legal Review
Employer responses to COBRA subsidy requests typically follow one of three patterns: immediate approval (most common when the employer already has a benefits continuation policy for executive departures and the request fits the existing framework); request for modification (employer agrees to partial subsidy, shorter duration, or a combination of direct payment and cash — accept the direct payment structure even at reduced duration rather than accepting full cash at any amount); or flat refusal (often based on a misunderstanding of the IRC Section 106 structure — a memo from the executive’s attorney addressing the tax treatment and mutual cost efficiency usually resolves this). The 21-day consideration period provides time for this negotiation to proceed without rushing. If the employer refuses entirely, the fallback position is to request that the cash health coverage payment be structured as a grossed-up amount — i.e., the employer pays enough gross cash to deliver the after-tax COBRA equivalent, acknowledging the tax cost explicitly in the agreement.
Action: Respond to employer counter with written analysis. Engage attorney for any legal review requests from employer counsel.
5
Final: Do Not Sign Without These Three COBRA Protections in the Agreement
Before signing any separation agreement that includes a health coverage benefit, verify that three elements are present: (1) the payment is structured as a direct employer premium payment to the COBRA administrator or carrier — not as a cash allowance or reimbursement to the executive; (2) the agreement specifies the exact coverage tier and the monthly premium amount, or references a mechanism for determining the premium if rates change; and (3) the agreement addresses what happens if the executive obtains new employer-sponsored coverage before the subsidy period ends — typically, the subsidy terminates upon new employer coverage eligibility, but the agreement should specify this rather than leaving it to later dispute. An agreement that lacks any of these elements creates ambiguity that may cost the executive the tax exclusion benefit or result in a dispute over the subsidy amount during the transition period.
Action: Verify all three structural elements before signing. Do not sign if payment is structured as cash reimbursement rather than direct payment.
6. Negotiation Scripts: Exact Language for Three Key Conversations
The conversations below represent the three most common points in a COBRA subsidy negotiation where the right framing determines the outcome. Each script is designed for use in a professional context — an HR meeting, a call with the employer’s legal team, or a written counter-proposal — and uses language that positions the request as a standard professional practice rather than an unusual demand.
Executive to HR Director
“I’ve reviewed the draft agreement and I’d like to discuss one structural adjustment to the health coverage component. The current draft includes a $[X] cash health coverage allowance. I’d like to explore restructuring that as direct employer-paid COBRA premiums under IRC Section 106 rather than a cash payment. From the company’s perspective, direct premium payment costs less than the gross-up required to deliver equivalent after-tax value in cash — and it provides me with uninterrupted group plan coverage through the transition. I’ve prepared a one-page comparison showing the cost difference for your review.”
Why this framing works: It opens with the employer’s interest (cost efficiency), uses the IRS code section by name (signaling professional preparation), and provides a written analysis rather than making an oral request. HR directors who have approval authority for benefit continuation decisions will recognize this as a standard structure and can often approve it without escalating to the compensation committee.
HR Director Response (Common)
“We typically handle health coverage through the cash allowance structure in our severance agreements. I’m not sure if we can pay COBRA premiums directly — I’d need to check with legal and benefits.”
This is the standard first response. It is not a refusal — it is a deflection to process. The appropriate follow-up is to request a specific response date and to provide a legal memorandum from your attorney addressing the IRC Section 106 structure to assist the legal review.
Executive Follow-Up
“Absolutely — I’ll send over a brief memo our attorney prepared that addresses the tax treatment and the payment mechanics. Most COBRA administrators accept direct employer premium remittance for terminated employees on an ongoing basis — it’s a standard election. If legal is comfortable with the structure, would benefits administration be able to set up direct remittance within the transition timeline? I’m happy to facilitate the coordination.”
This response removes the implementation objection proactively. Offering to facilitate the COBRA administrator coordination signals competence and reduces the employer’s administrative burden, which is often the unstated reason HR prefers cash payments — they require less post-separation coordination.
HR Director
“We’ve reviewed your request and we can accommodate direct COBRA payment for up to six months rather than the 18 months you requested.”
This is a partial approval — accept the structure (direct payment) and negotiate the duration. The employer has acknowledged that direct payment is viable, which is the most important structural concession.
Executive Response
“I appreciate the flexibility on the structure — direct payment is exactly the right approach for both parties. On duration, I’d like to work toward 12 months rather than 6. At the VP level with a family plan, the transition timeline to new employer coverage is realistically 6 to 9 months of active search plus a waiting period before new plan coverage begins. Twelve months would allow the transition without a coverage gap for my family. The cost difference between 6 and 12 months is [dollar amount] — I’m happy to accept a reduced base severance by half that amount to offset the extended coverage period if that helps the budget conversation.”
The offer to offset the extended coverage through a reduction in base severance demonstrates good faith and moves the negotiation from a confrontational dynamic to a joint problem-solving framework. It also frames the 12-month request in terms of the realistic transition timeline, which HR can document as a business justification for the benefit extension.
Executive to HR Director (after direct payment refusal)
“I understand the company’s preference for a cash structure. If direct premium payment isn’t feasible operationally, I’d like to request that the health coverage cash payment be calculated as a gross-up amount rather than the raw COBRA premium cost. The current draft pays $[COBRA cost] in cash — but after federal, Medicare, and state taxes at my bracket, I net approximately $[after-tax amount], which covers only [X] months of the [Y]-month COBRA period. A grossed-up payment of $[gross-up amount] would deliver the equivalent after-tax value of direct premium payment and reflects the same total economic benefit the company would be providing under either structure. I can share the calculation if that’s helpful.”
The gross-up request is more expensive for the employer than direct payment — it costs $33,000 more in the 18-month family plan example above. This framing makes direct payment look more attractive by comparison, often causing employers who initially refused direct payment to reconsider it when they see the gross-up alternative. If the employer accepts the gross-up instead, ensure the agreement specifies the exact gross-up amount calculated at the agreed tax rate, and verify with a CPA that the grossed-up severance does not trigger additional complications such as Section 280G golden parachute calculations for executives with change-of-control provisions.
7. Model Separation Agreement Language for COBRA Benefit
The following model language represents the structural framework that employment attorneys use to document an employer-paid COBRA benefit in a separation agreement. This is not a legal template — it must be reviewed and customized by a licensed employment attorney before use in any actual separation agreement. It is provided here to give executives a reference point for evaluating whether the language in their own agreement adequately protects the tax exclusion benefit and prevents disputes during the transition period.
Model Separation Agreement COBRA Provision — For Reference Only, Not Legal Advice
Section [X]: Health Benefits Continuation
Premium Payment Obligation. Subject to Executive’s timely election of continuation coverage under COBRA and continued eligibility thereunder, Company shall pay, or cause to be paid, Executive’s COBRA continuation coverage premiums directly to the COBRA administrator or insurance carrier on Executive’s behalf for a period of [12/18] months following the Separation Date (the “Subsidy Period”), or until the earliest of: (i) the date Executive becomes eligible for coverage under another employer-sponsored group health plan; (ii) the date Executive’s COBRA continuation coverage otherwise terminates; or (iii) the expiration of the maximum COBRA continuation coverage period under applicable law.Direct Payment Structure
Coverage Tier. The premium payments made by Company pursuant to this Section shall correspond to the same coverage tier in which Executive was enrolled immediately prior to the Separation Date — specifically, [Employee Only / Employee + Spouse / Family] coverage under the Company’s [Plan Name] group health plan. If the applicable COBRA premium changes during the Subsidy Period due to annual plan renewal or other adjustment, Company’s obligation shall be to pay the updated premium for the same coverage tier, and Company shall provide Executive with written notice of any such change within 10 days of the effective date of the premium adjustment.Coverage Tier Specification
Tax Treatment. The parties intend that the premium payments made by Company pursuant to this Section shall constitute employer contributions to an accident or health plan within the meaning of Section 106 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended, and shall be excluded from Executive’s gross income for federal income tax purposes. Company shall not report such payments as wages or compensation on Form W-2 or otherwise. Nothing in this Agreement shall be construed as a guarantee of any particular tax treatment, and Executive is encouraged to consult with a qualified tax advisor regarding the tax consequences of the benefits provided hereunder.IRC §106 Tax Exclusion Language
New Employer Coverage Notification. Executive shall notify Company in writing within five (5) business days of becoming eligible for coverage under another employer-sponsored group health plan. Upon such notification, Company’s premium payment obligation under this Section shall terminate as of the date Executive’s new employer coverage becomes effective. Executive’s failure to provide timely notification shall not affect the validity of this Agreement but may result in Company seeking reimbursement for premiums paid after the date of new employer coverage eligibility.Termination Trigger
Payment Mechanics. Company shall remit COBRA premiums directly to [COBRA Administrator Name / Insurance Carrier Name] no later than the 15th day of each month for which coverage is to be maintained. Company shall provide Executive with written confirmation of each premium payment within five (5) business days of remittance. In the event Company fails to remit a premium payment when due and such failure results in a lapse of Executive’s COBRA coverage, Company shall be responsible for any documented medical expenses incurred by Executive or covered dependents during any period of lapsed coverage caused by such failure, up to the amount of premiums that would have been paid.Payment Mechanics and Default Remedy
Why each clause matters for the executive: The direct payment structure preserves the IRC §106 exclusion. The coverage tier specification prevents the employer from later arguing that a lower-tier COBRA premium satisfies the obligation. The tax treatment clause prevents a W-2 reporting error that would trigger an IRS audit. The new employer notification provision is standard and reasonable — accept it. The payment mechanics clause creates an enforceable remedy if the employer misses a premium and coverage lapses.Executive Protection Checklist
This model language should be reviewed and modified by a licensed employment attorney in the jurisdiction where the executive was employed before inclusion in any actual separation agreement. The IRS and state tax consequences of employer-paid COBRA premiums depend on the specific facts, plan structure, payment mechanics, and applicable law as of the date of the agreement. Do not rely on this model language as legal or tax advice.
The Section 280G golden parachute trap for C-suite executives: For executives with change-of-control provisions in their employment agreements — typically C-suite officers and senior VPs at public companies or companies that have recently been acquired — COBRA subsidy payments made in connection with a termination following a change of control may be treated as “parachute payments” under IRC Section 280G if their aggregate value (including base severance, equity acceleration, and benefit continuation) exceeds three times the executive’s “base amount” (average W-2 compensation over the prior five years). Parachute payments above the threshold trigger a 20% excise tax on the excess amount paid by the executive and a loss of corporate tax deduction for the employer. The COBRA subsidy itself is typically a small component of the total package, but its value — especially an 18-month family plan subsidy at $2,400 per month — contributes to the 280G calculation and must be modeled before the separation agreement is finalized. Always engage a compensation attorney or CPA with Section 280G experience before signing a separation agreement that follows a change-of-control event.
8. When COBRA Is Not the Right Answer: Marketplace Plans vs. COBRA Cost Analysis
Not every executive should request a COBRA subsidy. For executives whose family qualifies for Affordable Care Act marketplace plan subsidies — because the post-separation household income drops below 400% of the federal poverty level — marketplace coverage may cost substantially less than COBRA even before any employer contribution. For single executives in excellent health with low anticipated healthcare utilization, a marketplace HDHP with a low premium and high deductible may be more cost-effective than maintaining the employer’s premium PPO plan at COBRA rates. The decision to negotiate for COBRA subsidy rather than marketplace plan cash should be made after a full cost comparison that accounts for the executive’s anticipated healthcare utilization, dependent coverage needs, provider network requirements, and marketplace plan availability in their geography.
Decision Factor
COBRA (Employer Group Plan Continuation)
ACA Marketplace Plan (Post-Separation Enrollment)
Premium Cost
Higher — 102% of full group plan cost including employer share. Family PPO: $1,800 to $2,600/month. No subsidy unless employer pays it in severance.
Potentially lower — ACA premium tax credits available if post-separation household income is between 100% and 400% of Federal Poverty Level ($15,060 to $60,240 for single filer in 2026; $31,200 to $124,800 for family of four). Above 400% FPL: no subsidy, premium comparable to COBRA.
Provider Network
Maintains existing provider relationships — same network, same in-network providers, no need to change physicians, specialists, or hospital relationships during the transition. Critical for ongoing treatment, specialist care, or complex medical situations.
New network required — marketplace plans have different provider networks than employer group plans. Existing specialists may not be in-network. In-progress treatments may require reauthorization. Not suitable if executive or dependents have ongoing specialist relationships.
Coverage Quality
Premium employer group plan quality maintained — the same plan with the same deductibles, copays, coinsurance, and out-of-pocket maximums the executive had during employment. No degradation in coverage quality during the transition.
Variable — marketplace plans at the Bronze and Silver levels typically have higher deductibles and out-of-pocket maximums than employer group plans. Gold and Platinum plans are closer in quality but at higher premiums that may approach COBRA costs without subsidy eligibility.
Enrollment Timing
Election within 60 days of qualifying event — retroactive to day after employment termination. No coverage gap if elected within the 60-day window.
Special enrollment period triggered — job loss qualifies as a special enrollment period for marketplace plans. 60-day enrollment window. Coverage begins the first day of the month after enrollment in most cases — potential 1 to 30 day gap depending on termination date.
Best For
Executives with family dependents, ongoing specialist relationships, expected high healthcare utilization, or income above 400% FPL where no marketplace subsidy is available. Always best when employer-paid subsidy is secured in severance negotiation.
Single executives with good health, income dropping below 400% FPL post-separation, no ongoing specialist relationships, and flexibility on provider network. Also suitable as a bridge for the portion of the transition after new employer coverage begins if COBRA was not negotiated.
The ACA marketplace subsidy calculation that changes the COBRA vs. marketplace decision: Job loss is a qualifying life event that triggers a special enrollment period for ACA marketplace plans. An executive who separates in June with $0 in earned income for the remainder of the year — or with substantially reduced income relative to the prior year — may have a post-separation household income that qualifies for significant premium tax credits that reduce marketplace plan premiums to a fraction of COBRA costs. The calculation uses projected annual household income for the current year, not prior-year W-2 income. An executive who earned $250,000 through June and will earn $0 for the remainder of the year has a projected full-year income of $250,000 — above 400% FPL and therefore not eligible for marketplace subsidies. An executive who separates in January with a departure package paid over Q1 and no anticipated additional income has a different projected income profile. Use the Healthcare.gov subsidy estimator with the executive’s specific income projection for the year of separation before concluding that COBRA is the only viable coverage option.
9. The Complete Executive Health Coverage Severance Checklist
The checklist below consolidates every action item from this guide into a single sequential workflow that can be executed within the 21-day separation agreement review window. Share this checklist with your employment attorney at the initial engagement meeting to ensure the health coverage negotiation is addressed in parallel with all other severance terms.
Executive Health Coverage Severance Negotiation Checklist — Complete Before Signing
Pre-Signature Action Items — Organized by Week
Week 1: Information Gathering and Attorney EngagementDays 1 to 7
☐ Retain employment attorney with executive severance experience before responding to HRPriority 1
☐ Request the exact group health plan monthly premium for your coverage tier from HR or benefits (not the COBRA notice — the underlying plan cost from the SPD)Priority 1
☐ Calculate 102% of group plan premium = your exact COBRA monthly rateUse COBRA Calculator
☐ Determine your combined marginal tax rate: federal bracket + 2.9% Medicare + applicable state rateWith CPA or attorney
☐ Run the gross-up calculation: COBRA annual cost ÷ (1 − combined marginal rate) = required gross cash equivalentDocument in writing
☐ Determine whether employer’s draft agreement offers cash allowance or direct payment — identify the structural gapAttorney review
☐ Check whether you are subject to Section 280G (change of control in prior 12 months) — if yes, flag for specialized tax analysis before any negotiation280G check
Week 2: Counter-Proposal SubmissionDays 7 to 14
☐ Submit written counter-proposal specifying direct employer COBRA premium payment, 12 to 18 month duration, coverage tier, and IRC §106 tax treatment languageAttorney drafts
☐ Attach one-page cost comparison showing employer cost of direct payment vs. gross-up cash alternativeNegotiation exhibit
☐ Provide attorney memo on IRC §106 structure to HR and employer legal team to facilitate their legal reviewExpedites approval
☐ Compare projected COBRA cost vs. ACA marketplace plan options at your post-separation income level — confirm COBRA is the right structure to negotiate forHealthcare.gov estimator
☐ Identify your COBRA administrator (typically a third-party vendor named in the plan documents) to facilitate direct payment logistics discussionImplementation prep
Week 3: Final Review and SignatureDays 14 to 21
☐ Verify final agreement language contains: direct payment structure (not reimbursement), specific coverage tier, exact premium amount or adjustment mechanism, new employer coverage termination trigger, and payment mechanics with default remedyAll five required
☐ Confirm no W-2 reporting commitment for COBRA premiums in the agreement — the IRC §106 exclusion requires that premiums not be reported as wagesTax treatment verified
☐ If in California, New Jersey, or Pennsylvania: confirm state tax treatment of employer-paid COBRA with state-licensed CPA before signingState-specific check
☐ Confirm COBRA election timing: you must elect COBRA within 60 days of the qualifying event (separation date) — the employer’s premium payment obligation begins upon your election, so elect promptly after signingTiming critical
Total Tax Savings from Successfully Negotiated Direct COBRA Payment vs. Cash Allowance (Family Plan, 18 Months, 44.9% Combined Rate)$17,780 to $33,000 depending on plan tier — secured at zero incremental cost to the employer under the direct payment structure
Every item on this checklist can be completed within the 21-day OWBPA review period. The employment attorney engagement in Week 1 is the only item with a meaningful cost — and that cost is recovered in the first two months of the tax-free COBRA subsidy for a family-plan executive at the VP or Director level. The checklist items that most commonly determine whether the COBRA subsidy is secured: obtaining the exact group plan premium before negotiation, submitting written counter-proposal language rather than oral requests, and verifying the final agreement specifies direct payment rather than cash reimbursement.
Calculate Your Exact COBRA Subsidy Value and Gross-Up Equivalent
Enter your plan type, coverage tier, and current employer group plan cost. The COBRA Health Insurance Cost Calculator calculates your exact monthly COBRA premium, your 18-month total subsidy value, and the gross-up cash equivalent your employer would need to pay to deliver the same after-tax value — the three numbers you need before your negotiation meeting.
Calculate My COBRA Subsidy Value →
Frequently Asked Questions
Is employer-paid COBRA in a severance package taxable income?
Employer-paid COBRA premiums are generally excluded from the employee’s gross income under IRC Section 106 when paid directly by the former employer to the insurance carrier or COBRA administrator as a continuation of the group health plan coverage. This exclusion applies during the severance period as long as the coverage remains part of the former employer’s group health plan and the premium payments are made on the employee’s behalf rather than reimbursed after the fact. By contrast, a cash severance payment designated for health insurance purposes is fully taxable as wages, subject to federal income tax at the marginal rate, FICA taxes, and state income tax. For an executive in a 44.9% combined tax bracket, the difference between these two structures on a $39,600 COBRA cost is $17,780 in taxes — making the payment structure the single most financially significant drafting decision in the health coverage section of a separation agreement.
How do I negotiate COBRA subsidy into my severance package?
The four-step approach: (1) Calculate the exact COBRA premium for your coverage tier — 102% of the employer group plan cost — and the gross-up cash equivalent at your combined marginal tax rate. (2) Present the employer with a cost comparison showing that direct premium payment costs them less than a grossed-up cash equivalent, making the request financially advantageous for both parties. (3) Submit a written counter-proposal through your employment attorney specifying direct payment to the COBRA administrator, coverage tier, duration, and IRC §106 tax treatment language. (4) Navigate the HR and legal review by providing a legal memorandum addressing the payment structure and confirming direct payment mechanics with the COBRA administrator. The negotiation must be completed before the separation agreement is signed — the 21-day OWBPA review period is the window.
What is a gross-up for health insurance in a severance package?
A gross-up for health insurance in a severance package is an additional cash payment calculated to cover the income taxes the executive will owe on a cash health coverage allowance, so that the after-tax value equals the full cost of COBRA premiums. The formula is: Gross-Up Amount = COBRA Premium Cost ÷ (1 − Combined Marginal Tax Rate). For an executive at a combined 44.9% marginal rate with a $39,600 COBRA cost, the gross-up is $39,600 ÷ 0.551 = $71,870 — of which $32,270 goes to taxes and $39,600 reaches the executive. The gross-up is always more expensive for the employer than direct premium payment, making the gross-up calculation a powerful negotiating tool: presenting it to the employer demonstrates that direct payment is the more cost-efficient structure and often converts an initial refusal into approval.
How long can an employer pay COBRA premiums in a severance package?
The maximum COBRA continuation coverage period for a qualifying event of employment termination or reduction in hours is 18 months. An employer can agree in a separation agreement to pay COBRA premiums for any duration up to this 18-month maximum — and many executive severance agreements include subsidy periods of 12 to 18 months for VP and above departures. The employer’s premium payment obligation typically terminates earlier than the agreed period if the executive becomes eligible for coverage under a new employer’s group health plan, if the executive fails to elect or maintain COBRA coverage, or if the COBRA coverage period otherwise expires. Negotiating for the full 18-month maximum is appropriate for executives with family coverage needs, ongoing specialist relationships, or anticipated extended transition timelines in a competitive job market.
Should I take COBRA or a marketplace plan during executive transition?
COBRA is generally the better choice for executives with: family dependents needing coverage, ongoing specialist or hospital relationships that are in-network under the employer plan, anticipated high healthcare utilization, or income above 400% of the Federal Poverty Level (approximately $124,800 for a family of four in 2026) that disqualifies them from ACA marketplace premium tax credits. A marketplace plan may be preferable for: single executives in good health with income dropping below 400% FPL post-separation (enabling significant premium tax credits), executives with no ongoing specialist relationships who can accept a provider network change, or situations where the employer refuses to subsidize COBRA and the executive must self-fund coverage at the full COBRA rate. Always run the ACA marketplace subsidy calculation using the projected post-separation annual income for the current calendar year — not prior-year W-2 income — before concluding that COBRA is the only viable option.
What happens to employer-paid COBRA if I get a new job before the subsidy period ends?
Under the standard separation agreement structure for employer-paid COBRA, the subsidy terminates when the executive becomes eligible for coverage under a new employer’s group health plan — typically the first day of the new employer’s enrollment period or the date new employer coverage becomes effective. The agreement should specify the notification obligation (typically 5 business days written notice to the former employer upon new coverage eligibility) and the termination date (the effective date of new coverage, not the notification date). The executive keeps any COBRA coverage that was paid for through the date of new coverage eligibility and loses the subsidy prospectively. An executive whose new employer has a 90-day waiting period before health coverage begins should discuss with their attorney whether the separation agreement can provide for continued COBRA payment through the waiting period before the new employer’s coverage takes effect.
Disclaimer: This article is for general educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute tax, legal, employment, or financial planning advice. The IRS tax treatment of employer-paid COBRA premiums described in this article is based on IRC Sections 105 and 106, applicable Treasury Regulations, and IRS guidance as of June 2026 and is subject to change. The application of the IRC Section 106 exclusion to any specific COBRA premium payment depends on the facts and circumstances of the individual case, the structure of the employer’s group health plan, the specific payment mechanics used, and applicable federal and state law — consult a qualified employment attorney and CPA before structuring any COBRA-related severance benefit. The model separation agreement language provided in this article is for illustrative and educational purposes only and is not a legal template — it must be reviewed, customized, and approved by a licensed attorney before use in any actual separation agreement. COBRA premium ranges, ACA marketplace premium estimates, and tax rate figures are representative estimates for 2026 and will vary by employer plan, geography, and individual circumstances. Section 280G analysis referenced in this article is a complex area of tax law requiring specialized legal and accounting expertise — always engage qualified advisors before finalizing any severance agreement involving a potential change-of-control situation. USFinanceCalculators.com does not provide tax, legal, insurance, employment, or financial planning advice and has no commercial relationship with any employment law firm, executive career transition coach, wealth manager, or financial services provider referenced or implied in this article.
